This is not the first time I have stood in this pulpit, though not
on a Sunday morning. About three years ago, Steve Van Kuiken,
Joanne Sizoo and I did a “service of healing
for those involved in abortion.”
It was very powerful. I’ve attended concerts here; I’ve attended
Sunday services here. I feel very much at home here. Yet I
realize that while some of you know me by name and some of you
have seen me before, or talked with me, you don’t know who I am.
Except for the bio–and how much can you put in one of those?–you
don’t know by what authority I come to speak with you this
morning; you don’t know what experiences I’ve had, what griefs or
what healings; what storms I’ve walked through or how long I’ve
been in them.
So I’ll begin by telling you some
things about me. For the most part, I’m an Optimist. My favorite
book of childhood was Pollyanna–the glad girl. My favorite
heroine of song and dance was Nellie Forbush, the corny Kansas
nurse from South Pacific. My optimism has served me well.
I remember the time I appeared before the Unitarian Universalist
Ministerial Fellowship Committee–that last hurdle before
ordination. The rumored test of that year was that you must have a
personal theology of “Evil” in order to convince the Committee you
are eligible for ministry. I prepared mine, and practiced it over
and over until it sounded spontaneous. I can’t recall now
everything I said, but it included something about Evil not being
something out there; evil, I said, was connected to the
shadow side of each of us; a personal struggle that all of us had
to endure. Someone on the Committee asked me, as the last
question, what was my personal. My mind went blank. I couldn’t
think of anything wrong with me. I was kind, and loving;
intelligent and thoughtful; I was optimistic and . . . good
looking. I could see at that moment no shadows on my own soul.
They aren’t going to pass me, I thought, pessimistically. So
I told them the truth. I said: I’ve been thinking
optimistically for the last two weeks, only positive thoughts to
get me up for this ordeal. And I can’t for the life of me think of
a negative thought at the moment.
They laughed, and they said,
Enjoy your ministry.
So I’m still an optimist. But like
the author of the reading Transcending Boundaries, I find
my optimism no longer shuts out negative experiences, no longer
makes me forget sorrows and travails, no longer shuts down the
grief process or dries up my tears. And this is a very good
thing. Too much optimism–that’s a shadow side I’ve struggled
against. I’ve had to learn to take solace from my griefs and
nurture from my fears.
The year I began seminary was such
a joyful year. I had taken a three-year sabbatical from my job in
the business world to write a novel. I had looked at the very
scary possibility of not returning to a well-paying job to throw
myself into the unknown of professional ministry. I had survived
bargaining with God: Okay, God, if this is what you want, see
that my house sells, I’ll have enough money to pay for my
education –and took the cash payment that came two weeks after
I put on the house on the market, and was accepted by the seminary
of my choice. I loved the work. I adored my community of
colleagues. I knew I had made the right choice.
The year I began seminary was the
most awful year of my life. My son, who loved being alone and had
taken a job in the mountains of Colorado where he was out of
contact for weeks at a time, disappeared. Vanished. Left no
reason, no trace. My family rallied round and we hired a private
detective. My sister and mother agreed to be the contact point
since I didn’t have a private phone at school. They told me to go
on with what I was doing. What a year.
There’s an old African American
spiritual that goes like this:
I’ve been
in the storm so long, children.
Been in the storm so long.
I’ve been in the storm so long, children,
Gimme a little time to pray.
That’s what it felt like. Being in
a big storm. You know how when the winds get so strong you can’t
keep your feet? You know how when the rain is so heavy that you
feel like you’re breathing water? You know how when the thunder
is so loud you can’t hear anything else, can’t believe anything
else is going on outside its precinct? That’s one of the ways I
remember that year. Been in the storm so long.
But an optimist can’t live in a
storm. It’s not in her nature. It’s not her element. I
retreated to hope. I took shelter in hard work. Oh, thank God
for being in seminary. I don’t know when I’ve had to work so
hard, or enjoyed it more. I could blow around, taking extra
courses, and create counter-winds you wouldn’t believe. I could
argue theory all day and the warmth of my arguments would dry out
rain or tear. I could talk philosophy all night and the sound of
my own voice drowned out anything and everything.
I was severely anemic that year and
I often fainted when I bled out each month. Been in the storm
so long.
I kept up the pace and increased
it. I did my required academic work in two years instead of
three. I got one of the best internships available way over on
the west side of the continent where I’d never been
before–Seattle, Washington. It was nothing like home, like the
Midwest. Nothing to remind me of anything I’d done or been
before. I could make myself up as a went along–myself and a life
without care to go with it. I graduated seminary with the prize
in academics. I was called to my first church before any of my
classmates–back in Seattle, where I’d never before and had no
family and no friends and nothing to remind me of anything I’d
done or been before.
I was lonely in Seattle because
it’s hard to make friends in the ministry, and I got married to a
man I really didn’t love, but who was kind. Been in the storm
so long.
I took on a second church because
they were both small and didn’t need me full time–at first. They
both grew. I was a successful minister. I joined the local
ministerium and did all kinds of volunteer work with them. Peace
rallies. Food pantries. Interfaith services. One of my
congregations bought a new and bigger church building and we had
room to bring in the outside world. I helped to start a shelter
organization for local gays and lesbians. I helped to start a
book store. We considered sanctuary and a pre-school. I appeared
on radio and television as the liberal minister spokesperson, the
one whose church didn’t mind if she spoke out on controversial
subject. I was busy.
My marriage wasn’t working and my
spiritual tank was running dry. I couldn’t sleep and I started to
have anxiety attacks. Been in the storm so long. Gimme a
little time to pray.
Gimme a little time.
But I had vast amounts of time. I
had all those hours when other people slept. And I did pray. I
blessed people and I blessed buildings. I asked for help for
anyone who needed it. Why that’s when I wrote most of the prayers
that ultimately went into the book that was printed this spring. I
could pray interfaith prayers that didn’t offend Christians and
Jews and Muslims at the same time. I was asked to pray
everywhere, including the chambers of the state senate. I was
good at prayer. But I was not touched by prayer.
From what I’ve seen and read, many
of us–most of us–when confronted by a personal storm of monumental
stature, get busy. We get busy to build a shelter against the
storm, and brick by brick we shut out the storm, and shut out the
rest of the world; shut out any possibility of being touched by
prayer. Three years of seminary and four years of serving everyone
but myself, and I knew that no matter how strong my shelter was,
I was still in the middle of the storm. I was angry. I thought I’d
gotten used to not knowing where my son was, and I had to admit to
myself that I hadn’t–that I couldn’t look at old photographs or
recollect old memories of joy. Seven years after my son
disappeared, I finally had to sit down with myself and reach into
this armor I had erected around the event, had to try to grasp a
reality that had no physical presence. I had to allow myself to
think negative thoughts. I had to learn how to pray all over
again.
I prayed let me feel my pain,
so that I might be relieved of it. I prayed, let me
consider the awful reality of what is–that my son is not living
among us and there is a very strong possibility that he is dead.
I prayed, Been in the storm so
long. Gimme a little time to pray. For the first time in
seven years, I wept. For the first time in seven year I prayed for
understanding and peace. May he rest in peace. May I know the
depth of my sorrow. May I feel the pain of my grief. May I feel
anything again, something else beside numbness, self- inflicted.
May I feel my appropriate anger. May I allow the storm to pass.
Funny thing about this kind of
experience. Once I got the knack of this deep, personal praying,
of getting in touch with my real feelings and my shadow and the
evil that I was creating in my physical body with my spiritual
denial, I wanted to share it. I told my family that I had to
allow that my son was dead so I might grieve. And they were so
angry. They told me I was an unnatural mother. They told me I had
to keep hoping. I was telling them they’d been in the storm so
long and needed a little time to pray. And they heard me saying to
them, You’re doing it wrong.
I told my colleagues at the next
ministers’ meeting that I had been in denial for seven years and
was just beginning to grieve the loss and to heal. And they were
angry. They told me I need to have faith. I was telling I”d been
in the storm so long. And they heard me say, I’m a person of
faith who can’t dispense faith. I knew then I wasn’t the only
person singing that song without even knowing the words. Been
in the storm so long, children. Gimme a little time to pray.
Mine is not a unique story except
for the details. There is no house that has never known grief.
There is no community that has not suffered sorrow, disappointment
or a fear of failure. My story is not even exceptional, except to
me. There is no individual here that could not tell a story of
loss and grief. Your community’s recent shared sorrow is yet an
open wound, and the telling of that story has only begun.
We all greet life, optimist or
pessimist, with a sense of anticipation for what might come. The
only difference, really, is that when we encounter loss or pain, the
pessimist may not be as surprised. The other ways we are so similar,
is in our reactions. Generally, in our society, we do grief badly.
We do storms badly. We think we build shelters against the
storm–shelters of work, shelters of denial, shelters of blame, or
glowing shelters of hope and faith--until we find that we are
shutting out not the rain, not the wind and not
the thunder, but one another. We are walling ourselves off from our
own feelings and, in the process, we destroy the bridges between us
and others.
Yvonne Seon, in our reading this
morning, called it “transcending boundaries.” And finally she had to
admit to herself that these boundaries, which were becoming harder
and harder to transcend, were walls of her own creation. “I’ve
created more of them since I was young,” she said, “and I”ve built
them higher and stronger than they once were.” We are such good
architects.
If we are really good at
mishandling our grief–if we don’t have enough emotional sense to
come in out of the rain; if we create armor against feeling–we can
literally make ourselves sick, or so angry that no one wants to be
with us–and isn’t that a kind of sickness?
I’ve been in the storm so long. Gimme
a little time to pray.
We need, at these times, not prayers
of hope and faith, but the kind of prayers that are wrecking balls
to our boundaries and our shelters. We need the kind of prayers
that get to the center of the storm, that open some windows to
relieve the pressure, that unlock doors to allow access to our
pain. We need the kind of prayers–and the time to pray–that gets to
the deep, quiet center of our being.
We need that quiet in order to hear
“the breath of our neighbor [that] calls us outside ourselves.” We
need that quiet in order to hear our own pain and to embrace – to
embrace that shadow side and make ourselves whole.
Ernest Hemingway had a line in one of
his short stories that went something like this: When we are
broken and allow ourselves to heal, we are often stronger at that
breaking point. But we need to abandon hope and faith, for the
moment, in order to pray for grief, for that is where the healing
begins.
Gimme a little time to pray.
Once this lesson is learned, I find we have to learn it all over
again, every time. My partner, Mary Ball, had surgery 12 days ago.
She’s been home for about a week. I find myself being her cheer
leader. Look how well you’re doing after such a short period of
time, I tell her. In just a few weeks you’ll be able to walk
with only a cane, I encourage her. And one day she said to me,
But today I feel like crying. And she said as if she thought
she were a failure for not heeding my cheers. I’ve been in the
storm so long. And I fought back more optimistic, encouraging
words and said, Then you ought to cry. I had forgotten for a
moment it is part of our healing.
I spoke in my story of letting go of
hope and discarding faith that I might reach the pain I had walled
away, and begin to heal. I do not want to leave the impression that
I have no place for hope or faith in my life, or yours. They, too,
are a part of healing. They are partners of grief. None can stand
alone. None, alone, can suffice weathering the storms of life.
And now there are these three: faith, hope and love. And the
greatest of these is love. When we love ourselves, we allow our
deepest feelings to begin the healing. Take a little time to pray.
Rev. L. Annie Foerster August 17, 2003
Mount Auburn Presbyterian Church
Cincinnati, Ohio Note: Rev. Foerster is retired
from the ministry. The last church she served was
St. John's
Unitarian Church in the Clifton area of Cincinnati.
|